No Pay, No Deliverables: What the Law Really Says About Withholding Client Files
This article will count 0.25 units (15 minutes) of unverifiable CPD. Remember to log these units under your membership profile.
South Africa’s small-firm accountants are being bled dry by non-paying clients. You’ve spent nights preparing annual financial statements, running tax calcs, drafting advisory notes, only for the client to vanish the moment your invoice lands. Calls unanswered. Emails ignored. The “valued client” you once bent over backwards for suddenly acts like you don’t exist.
So here’s the burning question that keeps many CBAPs awake at night: Can you legally hold onto client files until they pay?
The short answer: Yes, but only in the right circumstances. And understanding exactly where that line is (between your rights and your risks) could mean the difference between surviving and subsidising your clients’ businesses.
This isn’t about being petty. It’s about survival. Small practices cannot afford to bankroll clients who abuse the system. And yet, many accountants give away work for free out of fear, the fear of complaints, the fear of reputational damage, or the fear of “doing something illegal.”
This piece cuts through the noise. Let’s talk about your rights, your risks, and how to protect your practice without crossing ethical or legal lines.
The Harsh Reality: Accountants Are Working for Free
Let’s start with the lived experience. You’ve:
Completed the books.
Drafted the annual financials.
Prepped the SARS return.
Maybe even sat through a midnight Zoom/Teams call, hand-holding a client through their business mess.
And then? Silence.
Some accountants give in: They release the financials, hoping goodwill will get them paid later. Spoiler: it almost never does. Others hold back but lie awake worrying: “Am I even allowed to do this?”
Here’s the truth: South African law gives you tools to protect yourself. But they only work if you understand them and if you set up your contracts and processes properly from day one.
The Lien: Your First Line of Defence
A lien is the right to keep possession of someone else’s property until they settle their debt. In accounting, this could mean keeping back financial reports, working papers, or tax calcs until the invoice is paid.
Think of it like a mechanic refusing to hand over your car until you’ve paid for the repairs. The courts back this right. As Nagel et al. explain in Commercial Law (2019: 39.93):
“The contractor is also entitled to a lien on the work already completed by him. Where the client does not perform properly, the contractor is entitled to retain possession of the work until he receives proper payment.”
But here’s the catch: a lien requires lawful possession of a tangible thing.
That means:
If you physically hold the client’s file, you may be able to exercise a lien.
If you’ve already emailed them the documents, you no longer possess them in the legal sense. The client already has an “intelligible copy,” so you can’t claim to be holding it back.
This is why many accountants get burned: They press “send” before checking whether the invoice is settled. Once it’s in the client’s inbox, your common-law lien is gone.
⚖️ Key Case Law:
BK Tooling (Edms) Bpk v Scope Precision Engineering (Edms) Bpk (1978) — confirmed the principle of reciprocity.
Pheiffer v Van Wyk [2014] ZASCA 87 — clarified limits of a lien and the requirement of possession.
Horn v Ovofield (Pty) Ltd [2025] ZAECQBHC 7 — recent High Court ruling on lien as a defensive remedy and possession requirements.
In other words: possession is power. But possession in the digital age isn’t always clear. If your deliverables are electronic, your safest protection is a contract clause making payment a precondition to delivery.
Work Product vs. Client Originals
This is the distinction every accountant must tattoo on their brain.
Work product: Your working papers, draft financials, advisory notes, and tax calcs. These are generally considered the practitioner’s material and may be withheld in appropriate circumstances. But withholding must not breach statutory duties or professional standards.
Client originals: Their contracts, invoices, bank records, SARS forms, or CIPC certificates. These are theirs, and you cannot hold them hostage. If withholding them prevents statutory compliance, you could land in legal or disciplinary hot water.
👉 Example: You may be able to withhold a signed set of AFS until payment is received. But you cannot keep a client’s SARS eFiling login or refuse to hand over UIF documents if doing so would block them from meeting statutory deadlines.
This is where many accountants make fatal mistakes. Failing to return originals quickly can trigger POPIA breaches, complaints to regulators, and professional conduct charges.
The smart move? Return originals fast, but keep your work product until the EFT clears.
Reciprocity: No Pay, No Deliverables
The principle of reciprocity (legal Latin: exceptio non adimpleti contractus) is a CBAP’s best friend. It means that if two parties’ obligations are reciprocal, you can withhold your performance until they perform theirs.
Translated into accounting reality:
You agree to prepare financial statements for R10,000.
They don’t pay.
You don’t have to deliver.
The Supreme Court of Appeal confirmed that in bilateral contracts, obligations are presumed reciprocal unless the contract says otherwise.
⚠️ But beware: if your engagement letter says payment is due “regardless of delivery,” reciprocity falls away. And many generic engagement letters are vague, thus leaving you exposed.
Why Most Accountants Lose
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: Accountants often lose these fights not because the law isn’t on their side, but because their contracts are weak.
No reciprocity clause.
No lien clause.
No process for separating originals from work product.
That leaves practitioners negotiating from a position of fear: “If I hold this back, will I be reported to CIBA? Will SARS penalise me? Will my reputation suffer?”
Meanwhile, the client walks away with free work.
The Extra Fear: “They’ll Report Me to CIBA”
For many CBAPs, the biggest fear isn’t the unpaid invoice, it’s the spectre of being dragged before CIBA for professional misconduct.
Clients know how to weaponise complaints. They threaten to report you if you don’t hand over files immediately. The stigma of an ethics investigation (even if you’re cleared) can feel worse than the lost income.
But here’s the truth: If you follow the law, return statutory originals promptly, and have clear contract clauses, you’re on solid ground. Complaints may still be lodged, but contemporaneous documentation protects you.
How to Protect Yourself (and Sleep at Night)
Here’s the CBAP survival kit:
1. Bulletproof Your Engagement Letter
Insert explicit reciprocity and retention clauses. Example:
“The Practitioner reserves the right, in the event of non-payment, to withhold delivery of work product until all amounts due have been received. This does not extend to client originals required for statutory compliance.”
⚠️ Caveat: tailor this to your professional rules and, in high-risk cases, have it reviewed by legal counsel.
2. Separate Originals from Work Product
Tag and file from day one. Originals in one file, work product in another. No grey areas.
3. Return Essentials, Keep the Rest
If clients need documents to stay compliant with SARS, UIF, or CIPC, hand them over. Hold your drafts, reports, and analyses until you see the money.
4. Stay Ethical
Never breach POPIA. Never expose client data. Always communicate in writing when withholding work.
5. Document Everything
Emails showing unpaid invoices, proof that originals were returned, notices explaining lawful withholding. Paper trails defend you against clients and regulators alike.
The Emotional Toll
This isn’t just about law and contracts. It’s about dignity.
Every time an accountant hands over files without payment, it reinforces the toxic belief that our work has no value. That we’re just “cost centres” rather than trusted professionals.
And for CBAPs, unpaid invoices don’t just hurt businesses, they hurt families. They mean unpaid staff, missed school fees, or loans you can’t service.
This is why CIBA exists: To give you the backing, tools, and professional validation to enforce your worth. You’re not powerless. You’re not alone.
Compliance Checklist (Pin This Up)
✔ Explicit reciprocity clause in every engagement letter
✔ Lien/retention rights clearly stated
✔ Originals vs. work product separated on file
✔ Originals required for compliance returned promptly
✔ POPIA and confidentiality observed
✔ Written record of all communication with defaulting clients
The Bottom Line
Professional engagements are often reciprocal, but don’t assume. Check your contract. If it’s silent, fix it. If it’s vague, tighten it.
The law can protect you. But only if your paperwork and processes do.
Stop bleeding cash. Stop giving away free work. Stop letting defaulting clients push you around.
Because here’s the raw truth: If you don’t protect yourself, no one else will.
Final Word
If you’ve ever felt “held hostage” by defaulting clients, remember: You have rights. With the right clauses, the right processes, and the confidence to enforce them, you can protect your practice and your peace of mind.
And if a client ever threatens to report you to CIBA? Breathe. Complaints happen. But if you’ve acted lawfully, ethically, and documented every step, you’re on safe ground.
👉 Join CIBA and we’ll show you how to build contracts that protect your practice, your income, and your sanity.
⚠️ Disclaimer: This article summarises general principles of South African law and professional practice. It is not legal advice. Whether a lien or reciprocity right applies depends on your contract, possession, and regulatory duties. Practitioners should seek legal or professional guidance in specific cases.
