The Breaking Point: Are South Africans Now Paying Too Much Tax?
This article will count 0.25 units (15 minutes) of unverifiable CPD. Remember to log these units under your membership profile.
When more tax brings in less money — it’s not just a warning sign. It’s a reality. And South Africa may already be there. There’s a point where taxpayers stop being taxpayers. Not because they want to cheat the system, but because the system has simply become unaffordable. That’s the message behind the Laffer Curve, and it’s the central lesson both municipalities and National Treasury may now be learning the hard way.
As accountants, this moment matters — for our profession, for our clients, and for the country’s financial future.
📈 What Is the Laffer Curve — and What’s the Breaking Point?
The Laffer Curve shows the relationship between tax rates and revenue. At first, increasing tax rates brings in more money. But eventually, you reach a breaking point — the peak of the curve — where taxes become so high that people:
Work less,
Spend less,
Or stop complying altogether.
From that point on, every new tax hike results in less income for the state, not more. It's the economic version of squeezing too hard — the juice just stops coming.
🚨 Are South African Municipalities Already There?
Tshwane’s latest financials show a worrying trend: despite regular tariff increases, revenue from water, electricity, and other services is declining. Economist Dawie Roodt and councillor Lex Middelberg both say this suggests Tshwane has passed the peak of the Laffer Curve. Tariffs are too high, and residents are financially maxed out. It’s not just local government either.
🧾 Budget 2025: Treasury’s Close Call
The pushback against the proposed 0.5% VAT increase showed us that South Africans that the tax load — including bracket creep, rising fuel levies, and steep municipal rates — may already be too heavy. When the tax base is already under strain, piling on more isn’t a solution — it’s a recipe for economic and social fallout.
💸 Why This Matters for Accountants
Accountants are on the front lines of this breaking point — watching clients try to keep up, absorb new costs, or rethink their participation in formal systems. Here’s what to focus on:
✅ Advise clients on their rights regarding municipal tariffs — especially where charges don’t match actual service usage.
✅ Track Budget 3.0 (due 21 May), which is expected to adjust spending and tax plans following the VAT reversal.
✅ Use the Laffer Curve to help clients and stakeholders understand why more taxation isn’t always the answer — especially when service delivery breaks down.
⚖️ Municipal Tariffs Under Scrutiny
From Tshwane’s controversial cleaning levy to Cape Town’s fixed water charges based on property value, there’s growing concern that municipal pricing models are unfair, inefficient, and possibly unlawful.
National Treasury has already told municipalities: if you want to hike tariffs beyond the 4.4% inflation target, you need real justification — not just a percentage increase slapped onto last year’s fees.
📌 Bottom Line: Trust is the Real Currency
You can only raise taxes if people believe they’re getting something back. When that trust is gone — when water doesn’t run, power doesn’t flow, and streets don’t get cleaned — the whole system is at risk.
And right now, South Africa may be at the breaking point of the Laffer Curve.
❓ The Question We All Need to Ask:
Have South African taxes — national and local — already gone too far? Are we now taxing more, but earning less? Stay informed: Budget 3.0 drops 21 May, in answering that question — with data, with integrity, and with the voice of the people behind the numbers.
📣 Join the conversation: Follow CIBA for expert analysis and accountant-focused updates.
Source article: Moneyweb
