Police accused of buying used Kevlar as new

Old bulletproof vests returned by Johannesburg Metropolitan Police Department (JMPD) officers were allegedly stripped of their Kevlar and sold back to the department as new. According to Carte Blanche, a supplier was also allegedly paid R350 for every returned vest. 

The claims formed part of a Carte Blanche investigation, aired on 15 November 2026. It also examined allegations of missing equipment and irregular procurement contracts. Bennet "Berea" Madzonga, whose company was awarded an R11.4m vest contract mentioned in the investigation, denied wrongdoing.

For accountants, the case raises an important question about financial controls. Purchase orders, delivery records, and invoices might all match, but that doesn't necessarily mean the organisation received what it paid for.

For example, suppose a business orders 10 items but receives only four. The goods received record should flag the missing six before the invoice is paid.

But if someone is pressured into signing off on all 10, the paperwork could appear correct even though the stock is missing. A physical stock count or an employee speaking up might be the only way to uncover the problem. 

A signed contract doesn't guarantee honest suppliers 

Heynes Kotze, head of legal services at CIBA, says even a well-written contract can't prevent a supplier from acting dishonestly. “No contract can prevent the unethical, so it becomes more of an enforcement measure,” he says. 

The buyer and its lawyers are responsible for enforcing the contract, but accountants can help identify problems by checking what was delivered, paid for, and recorded. In cases involving returned equipment, that also means tracking what happens to old stock.

A similar case emerged in New York in 2017, when the city cancelled a contract with a company hired to dispose of old police bulletproof vests. Some had been resold on eBay, and used police vests were recovered during arrests. 

The contract required the vests to be destroyed or recycled to prevent misuse. However, prosecutors reportedly declined to pursue charges because the wording around recycling was too vague. 

Suspected fraud may trigger two reporting duties 

When an accountant finds suspicious payments or missing stock in a client's records, the first step is to establish what happened.

Heynes Kotze says accountants must follow the rules on non-compliance with laws and regulations (NOCLAR), which explain how to respond when a client or employer may have broken the law.

“You can ask the client to explain something that doesn’t add up, because that’s how you find out whether there is a problem at all,” he says.

If the findings meet the reporting requirements under the Financial Intelligence Centre (FIC) Act 38 of 2001, the matter must be reported to the FIC as soon as possible, and no later than 15 business days after the relevant facts become known. The client mustn't be told that a report has been made.

There's also a separate duty under section 34 of the Prevention and Combating of Corrupt Activities Act 12 of 2004. Directors, managers, partners, auditors, and others in positions of authority must report specified corruption offences, as well as suspected fraud, theft, and certain other offences involving R100,000 or more, to the Hawks.

Kotze stresses that reporting to the FIC doesn't replace the duty to report to the Hawks.

Accountants concerned about their legal responsibilities can access general legal support through CIBA's LegalHelpline, available to CIBA designation holders in good standing. Non-members who want access to this and other benefits can join CIBA here. 

Whistleblowers risk losing their jobs and their lives 

Reporting wrongdoing can have serious consequences. Heynes Kotze says whistleblowers can face anything from dismissal to death, pointing to the murder of Babita Deokaran.

Deokaran, a senior finance official at the Gauteng Department of Health, was shot outside her home on 23 August 2021. In the weeks before her death, she'd flagged around R850m in suspicious payments linked to Tembisa Hospital. 

To help protect accountants who report wrongdoing, CIBA has proposed an Accountants' Protection and NOCLAR Compliance Fund. 

The proposed fund would provide financial support, help with legal costs, and assist with relocation for accountants facing threats. It hasn't been established yet.

For more on the protections currently available, read our guide to whistleblower protection, which explains what the Protected Disclosures Act 26 of 2000 covers and where it falls short.

Next
Next

Rising costs hit nearly 70% of accountants