Fraud Fighters: Why SA Whistleblowers Still Fear Speaking Up
This article will count 0.25 units (15 minutes) of unverifiable CPD. Remember to log these units under your membership profile.
If your client’s bookkeeper blows the whistle tomorrow, would you know what happens next?
For accountants in practice, that’s not a theoretical question. Every day, fraud sits hidden in payroll systems, procurement deals, or expense claims. Often, the first person to spot it isn’t an auditor or regulator, it’s an employee brave enough to raise the alarm.
Half of all fraud worldwide isn’t caught by auditors. It’s exposed by whistleblowers. That should make us uneasy, because it means the credibility of our entire financial system doesn’t rest on audits, controls, or governance frameworks, it rests on ordinary people prepared to risk their jobs, reputations, and even safety to tell the truth.
But here’s the problem, in South Africa, the act of speaking up can end careers, destroy reputations, and even cost lives. Our legal framework (while improved since the promulgation of the Protected Disclosures Act (PDA) of 2000) is still worlds apart from international best practice. And for Chartered Business Accountants in Practice (CBAPs), that gap creates hidden risks, both for clients and for your own practice.
South Africa’s Framework: Strong Words, Weak Teeth
The PDA was designed to protect employees who expose misconduct. It covers criminal offences, legal breaches, health and safety dangers, and discrimination. Amendments in 2017 broadened its scope to include contractors and consultants, and added obligations for employers to establish disclosure procedures.
On paper, it sounds promising. In practice, the cracks are obvious:
Protection is limited. Volunteers, trustees, and the self-employed, often those closest to shady dealings aren’t covered.
Confidentiality isn’t enough. Anonymous reporting isn’t robustly protected, making whistleblowers vulnerable in small workplaces.
External reporting is restricted. Going straight to the media or a regulator is risky. Unless you’ve first exhausted internal channels, you could lose protection entirely.
No safety net. There’s no independent agency offering support, legal aid, or psychological help. Whistleblowers often face financial ruin for doing the right thing.
For CBAPs advising SMEs, these gaps matter. If a staff member inside a client’s business comes forward and isn’t properly protected, the fallout can land on your desk, from reputational damage to regulatory scrutiny.
Real People, Real Risks
The risks aren’t theoretical. They’re written into the lives of South Africans who dared to speak up:
Babita Deokaran (2021): A senior public finance official assassinated after flagging unlawful payments at Gauteng Health. Her murder shocked the nation and became a chilling warning for anyone considering speaking out.
GPAA Finance Manager (2025): Suspended for refusing to approve an irregular R21 million payment. He acted lawfully but was punished for his integrity.
SIU, Forensic, and Municipal Auditors: Repeatedly threatened, harassed, or victimized when uncovering misconduct. Some have had to relocate or step down to protect their families.
Kibiti Lephoto v National Institute for Humanities and Social Sciences: A CFO dismissed after exposing R52 million in irregularities. The court later ruled the dismissal automatically unfair — but only after his career was derailed.
Major Recovery Cases: Whistleblowers were central to asset recoveries of over R11 billion — including ABB (R2.55bn), McKinsey (R1.12bn), SAP (R1.16bn), Transnet (R710m), Eskom (R500m), and NSFAS (R191m). Without insiders speaking up, these recoveries would not have happened.
Other SOEs: From Eskom to Transnet, internal whistleblowers routinely face retaliation, constructive dismissal, blacklisting, and intimidation. The price of integrity is often exile from the profession.
These stories aren’t just headlines, they’re warnings. In a system where whistleblowers are punished instead of protected, fraud thrives. And accountants end up cleaning the mess.
What the World Gets Right
To see where South Africa falls short, look abroad.
United States: Rewards and Results
Enron. WorldCom. Two scandals that shook Wall Street so hard the US had to scramble. First came Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) which imposed tough rules, harsh penalties, and a promise: Whistleblowers won’t get fired for speaking up. But here’s the truth: SOX gave protection, not pay. The real “financial carrot” only arrived with the Dodd-Frank Act. That’s where the SEC Whistleblower Program was born and where the money is. If your tip leads to enforcement, you pocket 10–30% of whatever the regulators claw back.
The result? Since 2011, the SEC whistleblower program has clawed back over $2 billion and handed more than $720 million to insiders who spoke up. The lesson? Money talks and fraudsters get caught.
United Kingdom: Broad, But Not Perfect
The UK’s Public Interest Disclosure Act (PIDA) protects not just employees, but contractors, agency staff, and many NHS workers from day one. No need to “earn” two years of service first. But gaps remain: Volunteers and most self-employed people still fall outside of the acts protections. In June 2025, the rules were updated again: Whistleblowers can now safely report sanctions breaches to government regulators, a sign that the UK system continues to evolve, but also a reminder that it remains uneven.
European Union: Infrastructure, Not Lip Service
The EU’s 2019 Directive set a global benchmark. Any organization with 50+ workers must run internal reporting channels. Whistleblowers get free advice (and legal aid in some cases), plus a crucial shift in the law: Once you prove you blew the whistle and suffered for it, the burden flips, the employer must prove their action was justified. But here’s the catch: Protection only covers breaches of EU law unless a Member State extends it to national law and enforcement varies. On paper it’s infrastructure, but in practice, it depends on where you live.
Why South Africa Can’t Afford to Lag Behind
For CBAPs, whistleblowing isn’t an academic issue. It directly affects:
1. Economic Losses
The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners estimates that fraud costs organizations 5% of revenue globally. For SMEs, that’s survival-level money. Strong whistleblower systems recover losses before they spiral.
2. Corporate Governance
South African companies aiming for foreign investment or listings are judged against international governance standards. Weak protections make local businesses look risky.
3. Regulatory Compliance
Whistleblowers are early-warning systems for legal breaches. Without them, violations often escalate until SARS, CIPC, or the Competition Commission comes knocking.
4. Reputation and Trust
A single ignored whistleblower can tank years of reputation-building. For practices competing in competitive markets, credibility is everything.
5. Personal Liability for Accountants
When fraud is exposed late, CBAPs risk being accused of negligence, even if you were kept in the dark. A strong whistleblower culture among your clients is also protection for you.
What Needs to Change
South Africa’s PDA is a foundation, not a finished product. To truly protect whistleblowers and strengthen governance, reforms must include:
Reward Mechanisms: Align with the US model. Financial incentives drive reporting and improve detection rates.
Expanded Protection: Cover volunteers, trustees, self-employed individuals, and former staff.
Independent Oversight: A dedicated whistleblower protection agency with investigative powers and support services.
Anonymous Reporting: Secure, anonymous channels that actually work, especially for small businesses.
External Options: Remove the stigma and risk of bypassing internal channels. Sometimes the boss is the problem.
Where CIBA Steps In
CIBA has long recognized that South Africa’s whistleblower protections are not just legally weak but economically damaging. Accountants in practice see the fallout every day, from fraud losses to reputational harm. That’s why CIBA has gone further than commentary:
👉 CIBA has formally submitted a proposal to National Treasury for the creation of an Accountants’ Protection and NOCLAR Compliance Fund.
This proposed Fund is designed as a hybrid of the best global models, backed by constitutional rights and grounded in South Africa’s own legislative framework. It aims to close the gap between the laws on paper and the dangerous reality whistleblowers face.
Specifically, the Fund would:
Provide financial relief for whistleblowers who lose income or employment after making disclosures.
Cover legal costs to ensure fair access to justice, regardless of personal means.
Offer counselling, relocation, and reintegration support for professionals forced out of their roles or facing threats.
Compensate verified losses and assist with career rehabilitation to ensure professionals can rebuild their lives.
Operate a 24/7 helpline to give immediate confidential advice and link whistleblowers to emergency assistance.
Pool funding from modest employer levies, Treasury contributions, and (most innovatively) a penalty mechanism that redirects a portion of fines from guilty parties into the Fund.
Guarantee transparency and oversight through governance by a multi-stakeholder board, including CIBA, regulators, and civil society, with annual reporting to Parliament and audit by the Auditor-General.
The anticipated impact is huge: Even a 10% increase in whistleblower disclosures could yield billions in additional recoveries for the fiscus. The Fund would also turn the tide on South Africa’s chilling reality where compliance currently costs lives and careers.
For CBAPs, this is more than advocacy, it’s protection. A supported whistleblower is a protected accountant, and a stronger governance system means safer clients, safer practices, and a more trusted profession.
What CBAPs Can Do Now
While waiting for legislative reform, business accountants can take proactive steps:
Advise clients to build internal policies. Even small businesses can set up confidential reporting channels.
Educate clients on governance risks. Position yourself as the trusted expert who sees the bigger picture.
Offer whistleblower policy templates. Turn governance into a billable service instead of an admin headache.
Protect yourself. Ensure your engagement letters clarify the limits of your role if fraud goes undetected.
This isn’t just compliance, it’s an opportunity. CBAPs who help SMEs implement whistleblower frameworks stand out as forward-thinking advisors, not just number-crunchers.
The Bigger Picture
Whistleblowing is about more than fraud prevention. It’s about shifting business culture in South Africa. In communities where accountants are often the only professional voice, you are not just keeping books, you’re protecting livelihoods.
Stronger whistleblower frameworks mean:
Safer workplaces for employees.
Less leakage of scarce resources in SMEs.
More trust in South Africa’s markets.
And yes, more credibility and earning power for CBAPs.
Conclusion: Time to Catch Up
South Africa’s PDA gave us a start. But compared to the US, UK, and EU, our whistleblower protections are outdated, underpowered, and under-enforced. Until we reform, speaking up will remain dangerous and fraud will remain costly.
For accountants, that’s both a risk and an opportunity. The risk? Inheriting the fallout of unreported misconduct. The opportunity? Positioning yourself as the advisor who helps SMEs plug these governance gaps before they become scandals, because when whistleblowers are silenced, accountants pay the price too.
👉 Join CIBA and we’ll show you how to turn governance risks into billable services, while protecting your clients, your practice, and your community.
