Rethinking Taxation: Why Revenue Must Remain Conditional
This article will count 0.25 units (15 minutes) of unverifiable CPD. Remember to log these units under your membership profile.
A Different Way to Look at Tax
Tax is often treated as an unavoidable fact of life, a tool for governments to raise revenue. Yet, when you trace its roots, taxation is not an absolute right of the state. It is a conditional agreement between citizens and government, justified only when it genuinely serves the people who make the economy work.
In a country where the tax base is shrinking, public trust is eroding, and service delivery is inconsistent, it is time to revisit the moral and economic foundation of taxation itself.
Before Borders, There Were Rights
Long before the rise of governments, thinkers like John Locke and Jean-Jacques Rousseau believed that people held natural rights, such as rights to life, liberty, and property. Governments weren’t the origin of these rights. They were created to protect them.
Seen this way, taxation isn’t the foundation of civilization, it’s a deal. Citizens agree to be taxed only if the state upholds its side of the bargain: delivering justice, safeguarding property, and promoting the common good. When that duty is ignored, the moral case for taxation starts to crumble.
From Ownership to Stewardship
Adam Smith taught that a sound tax system should be fair, certain, convenient, and economical. Building on that wisdom, taxation today should be understood as stewardship, not ownership.
Governments do not own the wealth of their citizens. They are entrusted to collect and allocate funds only for specific, necessary, and time-bound purposes. When taxation becomes an open-ended entitlement, it risks morphing into exploitation rather than enabling prosperity.
For professionals in finance and accounting, this principle echoes through every audit, budget, and compliance process: transparency, accountability, and necessity must underpin every fiscal decision.
Taxation as a Conditional Economic Instrument
The real test of a good tax system lies in its adaptability. In times of crisis, higher taxes may be necessary to preserve stability. But when the economy recovers, tax burdens should ease to stimulate enterprise and innovation.
A thriving economy requires broad, low, and simple taxes that reward productive effort and investment. Before any increase in tax rates, fiscal efficiency should be demonstrated. Citizens must see value before they pay more.
Untaxed income reinvested through spending, business expansion, or community development often contributes more to national growth than excessive taxation channeled into inefficient systems.
Implications for Modern Fiscal Policy
Tax Morality and Compliance
Tax compliance is not only a legal matter, it is a moral contract. When taxpayers see clear evidence that their contributions are used responsibly and for visible public benefit, compliance follows naturally. Transparency, fairness, and credible outcomes strengthen tax morale far more effectively than enforcement alone.
Fiscal Transparency
Modern fiscal systems must make the purpose of every tax visible. Citizens and businesses deserve to know what they are funding, why it matters, and how long it will last. Emerging technologies such as real-time auditing, blockchain tracking, and performance-linked public reporting can transform how accountability is demonstrated.
Over-Taxation vs. Under-Governance
High tax rates paired with poor delivery erode both confidence and compliance. Excessive taxation suppresses entrepreneurship, investment, and job creation, while under-governance leaves the economy trapped in inefficiency.
As Friedrich Hayek cautioned, when government control expands without measurable results, individual liberty and innovation decline. Sustainable prosperity requires a balance: governments that tax lightly but deliver effectively.
A Framework for African Prosperity
For developing economies, taxation must be a means to enable growth, not a mechanism of dependency. Tax systems should fund the foundations of prosperity, infrastructure, education, and entrepreneurship, while allowing the private sector to innovate and expand.
Simplified compliance, fair enforcement, and digital transparency can empower small businesses and communities to thrive. When taxation funds opportunity rather than bureaucracy, it becomes a catalyst for economic sovereignty.
The Accountant’s Role
Accountants sit at the crossroads between law, ethics, and the economy. Beyond ensuring compliance, they are custodians of fiscal integrity and advocates for financial efficiency.
By promoting responsible taxation, grounded in necessity, transparency, and fairness, accountants strengthen the social contract that underpins national prosperity. In this sense, they are not just record-keepers of revenue but architects of public trust.
Conclusion: When Tax Serves, It Endures
Taxation exists because people do, not the other way around. When it remains conditional upon serving citizens’ rights and economic growth, it sustains a just and prosperous society. But when it becomes a tool of control or entitlement, it undermines both liberty and development.
The future of taxation in South Africa, and across Africa depends on how well we remember that principle. Before there was revenue, there was existence. And before government, there were people.
