Tax Morality and Risk: Are You Managing More Than Just Compliance?
This article will count 0.25 units (15 minutes) of unverifiable CPD. Remember to log these units under your membership profile.
What drives a person or business to pay tax honestly—even when they know they could bend the rules without getting caught?
For many accountants and tax practitioners, the answer has traditionally been “because the law says so.” But in today’s environment of heightened scrutiny, stakeholder pressure, and public transparency, the moral side of tax is just as important as the legal side—especially if you're advising clients who want to stay out of SARS’ crosshairs and keep their reputations intact.
Here’s why tax morality and risk management aren’t just textbook topics—they’re real-world issues that impact the bottom line.
Tax Morality: More Than Just Compliance
We all know clients who ask: “How little tax can I legally get away with?” But there’s a difference between avoiding tax (legal) and evading tax (illegal). Still, somewhere in the middle lies a grey zone: Are we playing by the letter of the law, or the spirit of it?
High trust = high tax morale. When taxpayers believe government uses tax revenue wisely and fights corruption, they’re more willing to pay. When they don’t, morale drops—and with it, compliance.
Good services = better attitudes. If clients feel like they’re getting value (infrastructure, safety, education), they’re more likely to pay without a fight.
Fairness matters. People want to believe the system taxes the rich and supports the poor. When this breaks down, so does the social contract.
As an accountant, your role isn’t just to calculate figures—it’s to guide clients in being good corporate citizens. That matters for long-term business sustainability, not just SARS audits.
Two Mindsets, Two Worlds
There are two dominant mindsets businesses adopt when it comes to tax:
Agency Theory (Letter of the Law):
Businesses exist to maximise shareholder value. Tax is an expense. The goal is to minimise it legally, even if it means exploiting loopholes. But this can trigger reputational damage—even if it’s legal.Stakeholder Theory (Spirit of the Law):
Businesses are part of society. They aim to create value for all: clients, employees, government, and the public. Here, tax isn’t a burden—it’s a contribution. The goal? Pay a fair share, build trust, and protect brand value.
Tax Risk: It’s Not Just About SARS Penalties
Whether you're in practice or in-house, tax risk is real. And like any other business risk, it must be managed proactively—not just cleaned up after the fact.
Here’s a breakdown of the four main types of tax risk your clients (or your company) could face—and why ignoring them is risky business.
1. Operational Risk
This is the risk that your everyday business operations—billing, accounting, recordkeeping—don’t align with tax law requirements.
What this looks like:
VAT invoices missing compulsory fields
Systems that don’t calculate VAT correctly
Manual processes that cause misclassification of income or expenses
Real risk: These issues may not come up immediately, but if SARS audits or reviews your systems, the business could owe back taxes, penalties, and interest.
✅ How to manage it: Automate where possible. Make tax compliance part of your process flow— not an afterthought. Build controls into accounting software and review transactional templates regularly.
2. Compliance Risk
This is the risk of missing deadlines, underreporting income, or failing to meet SARS obligations—even by accident.
What this looks like:
Late submission of returns (income tax, VAT, PAYE)
Provisional tax miscalculations
Forgetting to submit supporting schedules
Real risk: Non-compliance attracts penalties, interest, and triggers audit flags. Repeated offences raise suspicion—even when unintentional.
✅ How to manage it: Maintain a tax calendar. Use task tracking tools. Build in double-checks for key returns. Small firms should engage reliable practitioners; larger ones need proper internal review processes.
3. Interpretation Risk (Tax Uncertainty)
Tax law is complex and constantly evolving. Interpretation risk arises when there’s uncertainty around how the law applies to specific facts or transactions.
What this looks like:
Unsure if a transaction qualifies for a VAT zero rating
Disagreement over what constitutes a "permanent establishment" in cross-border services
Using tax losses in a way SARS later challenges
Real risk: If SARS or a court disagrees with your interpretation, it can lead to significant tax liabilities—even on past transactions. In major transactions, the risk is amplified.
✅ How to manage it:
Get advance rulings from SARS
Obtain written tax opinions (internal or external)
In high-risk scenarios, get counsel opinion or double review
Train teams regularly on current legislation
4. Reputational Risk
Tax is now a public issue. If your tax practices are perceived as unethical—even if they’re legal—you may face backlash from clients, media, and regulators.
What this looks like:
Public outrage over low effective tax rates
Being named in media for “aggressive tax avoidance”
Loss of trust among stakeholders
Real risk: Reputational damage can cause customer boycotts, staff unrest, or even share price drops (as seen with Starbucks and MTN). It’s not about what’s legal—it’s about how you’re seen.
✅ How to manage it:
Promote transparency through voluntary disclosures
Align your tax strategy with corporate values
Educate stakeholders on how you create value—and pay your fair share
Avoid aggressive schemes that look bad in hindsight
So, What Should You Do?
Whether you’re running a tax practice or working in finance, it’s time to ask:
Are we just managing compliance, or also managing our reputation?
Are we helping clients minimise tax, or optimise their tax contribution in a way that builds long-term trust?
Are we reactive or proactive when it comes to risk?
Tax isn’t just about numbers anymore—it’s about trust, transparency, and responsibility.
If you want to futureproof your practice, avoid client reputational disasters, and charge more for strategic advice, tax morality and risk management are services you can’t afford to ignore.
Final Thought
Clients expect you to keep them safe, not just compliant. And that means helping them do the right thing—before SARS, the media, or their customers come knocking.
Want to turn this into a billable advisory service? Start by talking to your clients about their tax strategy, not just their tax return.
