NPV or RIP, Pick the Right Project or Pay for It Later
This article will count 0.25 units (15 minutes) of unverifiable CPD. Remember to log these units under your membership profile.
If you or your clients are spending money on equipment, expansion, or new products, you need more than just a gut feeling to decide if it is the right move. Capital budgeting is how you test if an investment makes sense. It helps you back up your decisions with numbers, and more importantly, with confidence.
Most business owners, and some accountants, avoid it because it sounds technical. But capital budgeting is simply a process for deciding whether spending money now will pay off later. If you do it right, it helps you make smart, low-regret decisions that protect your business and keep your reputation intact.
This article explains capital budgeting and investment appraisal in clear terms, focusing on how they apply to everyday business decisions. Whether you are advising clients or making decisions inside a company, these are tools you need to get comfortable with.
What Is Investment Appraisal and Why Does It Matter?
Investment appraisal is the process of working out if a long-term investment is worth it. This includes things like buying new machinery, launching a product, or opening a new branch. These are not quick decisions that you can undo later. Once the business commits, it is in for the long haul.
Getting it right means the investment adds value, supports growth, and creates a return over time. Getting it wrong means cash flow pressure, wasted time, and possibly explaining to a frustrated director or shareholder why things are going off track.
This is why business owners and finance teams need capital budgeting. It gives you a structured way to test if an investment is going to work. And it is not just about financial return. More and more, businesses need to consider employee impact, customer experience, and environmental consequences. But if the numbers do not make sense, the rest will not matter for long.
The Main Appraisal Methods
There are a few ways to evaluate an investment. Not all are equally useful, and some can lead you astray if used incorrectly. Here are the ones you will see most often.
Accounting Rate of Return (ARR)
ARR is based on accounting profit. It is easy to calculate but not reliable. It includes things like depreciation, which is not a real cash flow. ARR often compares results to arbitrary targets. It might be useful for showing past performance, but it is not the best tool for forward-looking decisions.
Payback Period
This method looks at how long it takes to recover your investment. It focuses on cash coming in and tells you how quickly you get your money back. That is helpful when cash is tight, but it ignores everything that happens after the payback period. You could walk away from a highly profitable project just because it takes one extra year to pay back.
Discounted Payback Period
This improves the previous method by accounting for the time value of money. It gives a better sense of the real cost of time, but still does not tell you anything about the total profitability.
Profitability Index (PI)
This method shows how much value is created for every rand invested. A result above one means you are adding value. This is helpful when you need to compare projects or decide how to allocate limited capital.
Net Present Value (NPV)
NPV is the most reliable method. It calculates the present value of all future cash flows, subtracts the initial investment, and shows you what the project is worth today. If the NPV is positive, the project creates value. This method focuses on actual cash, not accounting profits, and it allows you to include risk through a discount rate.
Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
IRR gives you the rate of return the project is expected to earn. It is easier to explain to clients and directors because it gives a percentage. However, IRR must be compared to a risk-adjusted rate to be meaningful. On its own, it can lead to poor decisions.
The Capital Budgeting Process That Works
Capital budgeting is not just about running the numbers. It is a full process that includes:
Identifying all available options
Forecasting the cash flows and identifying risks
Choosing the right discount rate to reflect the level of risk
Applying NPV or IRR, with payback used as a secondary check
Considering the non-financial impact of the decision
Making the final decision based on the full picture
Reviewing the outcome once the project is running
The last step—reviewing your decision—is often missed. But it is where you learn the most. If your forecasts were wrong, find out why. If the decision added value, understand what worked. That is how you improve your financial leadership over time.
Where People Usually Get It Wrong
The numbers might look simple, but there are common mistakes that can seriously affect your decision:
Including sunk costs: Money already spent is gone. Do not include it. It does not help you decide what to do now.
Ignoring opportunity costs: If you use an asset instead of selling it, the foregone cash is a cost.
Leaving out working capital needs: Projects often need more inventory or create slower debtor collections. That is real cash going out and must be included.
Adding depreciation or finance charges: These are not real cash flows and must be excluded from the analysis.
Skipping the tax calculation: Always work out the tax effects separately. Include wear and tear, recoupments, and anything else that affects real cash.
Using the wrong discount rate: If the project increases your risk, then using your current average cost of capital is not enough. Adjust it to reflect the real risk of the project.
Terminal Value and Continuing Value
If a project is expected to continue beyond the forecast period, you will need to estimate a terminal value. This involves assuming a stable growth rate and calculating what the investment will be worth at that point. These assumptions need to be realistic and clearly explained. Overstating the terminal value can make a weak project look good.
Sensitivity Analysis: Your Risk Check
No forecast is perfect. Sensitivity analysis helps you test how the result changes if one or two inputs go wrong. What happens if sales are lower than expected, or costs go up? This shows you where the real risks are and whether the investment can handle a few surprises. It also helps prepare your client or director for what to expect if things do not go according to plan.
Final Thoughts
Capital budgeting is not just for accountants in large corporations. It is essential for anyone advising on or making financial decisions about long-term investments. You do not need to be a financial modeller. You just need to follow a structured process and ask the right questions.
If you get the method right, you will help your clients or company make smarter decisions. That builds trust, adds value, and shows your worth as a finance professional. Whether you are helping a client invest in machinery or guiding an internal project team on a new expansion, your ability to apply capital budgeting principles makes you more valuable.
If you want to stand out in the profession, this is one of the tools that will get you there.
Join us for a CIBA CPD; Stop Guessing, Start Growing, Capital Budgeting That Works
Still Guessing Which Projects to Back? That’s a Costly Habit.
One wrong “yes” can wreck a budget. One smart “no” can save a business.
If you're tired of playing eeny-meeny with investment decisions, it’s time to upgrade your toolkit.
💥 Now available as a recording – R345 VAT incl.
Free for CIBA Channel 2 subscribers. Because growth shouldn’t come with guesswork.
Capital Budgeting That Works: The Recording
📅 Originally aired: 4 June 2025
🎥 Format: Recorded Session
⏰ Duration: 2 Hours | 🎓 CPD: 3 Units
🧠 Category: Management Accounting | Channel 2: Growth
What’s In It for You?
This isn’t theory. It’s a playbook. Learn how to:
✅ Back every project with numbers that hold up under pressure
✅ Master NPV, IRR, Payback Period & Profitability Index—and when they lie
✅ Handle incomplete data, risk, tax, and working capital like a pro
✅ Present investment cases to boards and clients with confidence
✅ Turn capital budgeting into a paid service (yes, clients will pay for this)
Why You Need This
Most accountants either say yes too quickly—or too late. Either way, someone pays.
This session shows you how to protect your reputation and your bottom line.
Whether you’re advising clients or sitting at the strategy table, you’ll walk away with practical, billable skills.
🎯 Channel 2 members watch for free.
💳 R345 incl. VAT for everyone else.
Access this CPD here.
Heading 4
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.
List item - monospace
List item - monospace
List item - monospace
