From Numbers to Clues: How Analytical Procedures Crack the Case in Reviews

1 Oct

Preview

This article will count 0.25 units (15 minutes) of unverifiable CPD. Remember to log these units under your membership profile.

Independent reviews are not audits, but they are also not a casual glance at the books. They live in the space where professional scepticism meets practical detective work. The tool that brings everything together is analytical procedures. They help you spot patterns, highlight risks, and give confidence that the numbers make sense.

Done properly, analytical procedures do more than tick an ISRE 2400 requirement. They save you time, protect you from risk, and open the door to valuable conversations with your clients.

Why Analytical Procedures Matter

Think of analytical procedures as your magnifying glass. You are not digging through every single invoice, but you are looking at the big picture to see if the financial statements hang together.

If revenue went up 40 percent while expenses stayed flat, you should raise an eyebrow.
If debtor days doubled compared to last year, there is a cash flow issue waiting to be uncovered.

The point is not to prove every number beyond doubt. The point is to see whether the overall story makes sense, and to ask the right questions when it doesn’t.

What You Need to Do

ISRE 2400 requires analytical procedures at both the planning and execution stages. Here is what you need to cover, with a bit more detail to make it practical:

Understand the Business

Before you run a single ratio, you need context. A farming cooperative deals with seasonal income, weather risks, and input costs that rise and fall sharply. A retail store focuses on daily sales, stock movement, and customer returns. What is normal for one industry is completely abnormal for another. When you know the business, you know what to expect, and what to question.

Compare Periods

Looking at this year versus last year is where the stories start to reveal themselves. A big increase in sales might not be good news if expenses climbed in step. Stable numbers can be just as concerning. If fuel costs stayed flat during a year when global prices spiked, you need to ask why. Year-on-year comparison is not about proving growth, it is about checking whether the movements fit the reality of the business.

Use Ratios

Ratios are the shortcuts that help you cut through the clutter. Gross margin, debtor days, inventory turnover, and current ratio can tell you in seconds what pages of numbers cannot. If debtor days suddenly double, the business probably has weak credit control or struggling customers. If gross margin drops, it could be pricing errors, higher costs, or excessive discounts. Ratios are not just calculations, they are prompts for deeper questions.

Connect the Statements

The financial statements must tell one consistent story. If revenue increases, receivables or cash should move in the same direction. If PPE doubled, there must be cash outflows or financing to back it up. If liabilities climb, look for the related expense or asset. Analytical procedures here are like solving a puzzle: every piece must fit. If something is missing, it may point to incomplete or misstated information.

Talk to Management

Analytical procedures are not done in silence. They exist to trigger conversations. When you see anomalies, ask management to explain. Sometimes the answer will be simple, like a once-off repair or a new product line. Other times, the explanation may expose deeper risks. Always document both the anomaly and the response. These conversations often lead to advisory opportunities too. Highlighting poor debt collection or margin pressure positions you as more than a reviewer, you become the trusted advisor.

What You Can Do to Add Value

Beyond the basics, you can add real impact with a few extra steps:

Trend Analysis: Look at three to five years, not just one. A “growth” year may just be recovery from a prior dip.
Industry Benchmarks: Compare your client’s numbers with peers. A margin of 15 percent when the industry average is 30 percent is a problem worth exploring.
Common Size Statements: Express every expense as a percentage of revenue. Suddenly admin costs that looked small in rands jump out when they leap from 5 percent to 12 percent of sales.
Visuals: A simple chart can reveal spikes, drops, or unusual seasonality faster than a table of figures.
Monthly or Quarterly Breakdowns: Year-end totals often hide unusual recognition. A December miracle in revenue may actually be aggressive cut-off practices.

Real World Examples

The Shrinking Margin: A retailer reports booming revenue, but gross profit margins collapse from 40 percent to 25 percent. Discounts and poor pricing are killing profitability.
The Ballooning Debtors: A service company doubles turnover, but receivables triple. The truth is that half of their customers have not paid in six months.
The Year-End Spike: A farm shows stable annual revenue, but 60 percent of sales were booked in March. It is either a very good March or aggressive revenue recognition.

Why This Matters to You

Analytical procedures are more than compliance. They save time, reduce risk, and give you powerful talking points with clients. For practice owners, this is how you move away from “cheap compliance work” and toward advisory services that clients will pay more for. For accountants in commerce, this is how you protect yourself from liability and prove your worth to management.

Independent reviews are about more than conclusions. They are about telling the financial story honestly and clearly. When you use analytical procedures well, you are not just reviewing. You are building trust, protecting businesses, and creating value. And that is exactly the kind of work CIBA members are known for.

Join us for a lice VPD on: The Reviewer’s Edge, Finalising & Reporting with Impact – 6 October 2025

🚀 The Reviewer’s Edge: Finalising & Reporting with Impact
📅 6 October 2025 | 🕑 14:00 – 16:00 | 🎓 3 CPD Units

Picture this: you’ve just wrapped up another set of financials, but instead of relaxing, you’re worrying—did you cover everything? Will SARS or CIPC find a gap?

This 2-hour live session flips the script. Finalisation and reporting under ISRE 2400 isn’t just compliance—it’s your chance to protect clients, boost credibility, and add billable value to your practice.

🔥 Free for all CIBA designation holders
💼 R345,00 VAT incl. for non-members

What you’ll walk away with:
✅ How to turn your Independent Review conclusion into a money-making service
✅ Pitfalls that land accountants in hot water with SARS & CIPC—and how to avoid them
✅ Drafting and delivering a rock-solid Independent Reviewer’s Report
✅ Handling tricky scenarios (going concern, misstatements, scope limitations)
✅ Packaging Independent Reviews as a service clients actually pay for

🎤 Presenter: Leana van der Merwe, Technical Manager at CIBA | 18+ years in accounting & governance

🔗 Register here

💡 If you think Independent Reviews are “just admin,” think again—this is where credibility and income meet.

Choose Your Path to Exclusive Insights

Stay ahead in the world of accounting with premium content designed for professionals like you. Access expert articles, industry trends, and essential resources. Become a CIBA member and claim your CPD hours from CIBA.